by Achadu Gabriel, Kaduna

The Upper Customary Court, Kaduna, has discharged and acquitted Mr. Victor Balogun, who was standing trial on a charge of alleged criminal intimidation against journalist Idibia Gabriel.

Delivering judgment on 9th November, 2026, the court upheld the defence’s No-Case Submission and discharged and acquitted the defendant, Victor Balogun.

The application, a No-Case Submission filed pursuant to Section 314 of the Kaduna State Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2017, was in Suit No. UCC/132CR/2025, Commissioner of Police Vs Victor Balogun.

Mr. Balogun was arraigned on a First Information Report (FIR) alleging criminal intimidation and criminal trespass, offences said to be contrary to Sections 377 and 286 of the Penal Code Law, Cap 110, Laws of Kaduna State, 1991. He pleaded Not Guilty to the alleged offence.

In proof of its case, the prosecution called only two witnesses. The complainant testified as PW1, while Inspector Bulus, the Investigative Police Officer (IPO), testified as PW2.

The prosecution tendered only one exhibit – the statement of the defendant, admitted as Exhibit PP.1 – and thereafter closed its case. The defendant did not cross-examine PW2.

PW1 informed the court that, on 26/06/2025, he received a call from the defendant, following an online report about a raid carried out by the Special Task Force at the complainant’s Hotel, De-Jays Hotel, Ungwan Boro, at Sabon Tasha, Kaduna.

According to PW1, the defendant allegedly threatened that, if he did not withdraw the online report which the defendant found to be offensive, the defendant said he could be “so dangerous.”

Inspector Bulus, PW2, told the court that he took the statement of the defendant, which he tendered as Exhibit PP.1. In that statement, the defendant denied committing the alleged offence.

Mr. Balogun’s defence, led by Raymond Emeto & Co., anchored its No-Case Submission on a crucial admission by the IPO himself.

“Immediately, the Police investigation was raised to the MTN Communication requesting them to furnish us with the audio calls of both the parties, but they refused. Since the Complainant did not have any voice record to back the complaint, we were left with no option than to charge the matter to court.”

The defence submitted that, from the totality of evidence led, the prosecution has not established a prima facie case against the defendant to move the court to compel him to enter his defence.

The defence formulated a single issue for determination: “Whether the Prosecution has made out a prima facie case of Criminal Intimidation against the Defendant.”

Citing Section 286 (1) of the Penal Code Law, Cap 110, Laws of Kaduna State, 1991, the defence reminded the court:

“Whoever threatens another with any injury to his person, reputation or property or to the reputation or property of anyone in whom that person is interested, with intent to cause harm to that person or to cause that person to do that which he is not legally bound to do or to omit to do any act which he is legally entitled to do as the means of avoiding the execution of such threats, commits criminal intimidation.”

The defence argued that to secure a conviction for criminal intimidation, the prosecution must place evidence tending to show all the ingredients:

a. The act of threat (Actus reus);

b. Target of the threat;

c. The requisite mens rea (intention).

“The Prosecution has failed to establish any threat whatsoever as could be seen from the evidence of PW2 as per above quoted against the Defendant, as there is nothing before the Court to establish this basic element,” the defence submitted.

The defence relied on a string of authorities to support the application:

1. FAGORIOLA Vs FRN (2014) All FWLR (Pt. 724) 74* — That a No-Case Submission is available to a defendant at the close of the prosecution’s case, where the evidence led fails to meet the essential requirements or elements of the offence charged.

2. Section 313 of the Kaduna State Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2017 and IGP Vs MARKE (1956) NRNLR 97* — That where at the close of evidence in support of the charge, it appears to the court that a case is not made out against the defendant sufficiently to require him to make a defence, the court shall discharge him.

3. F.R.N. Vs BANKOLE (2012) FWLR (Pt. 629) 1150 @ 1161 (Pp. 1184-1185, Paras F-D)* — That the prosecution has failed to prove the elements of the alleged offence.

In IGP Vs MARKE (Supra), the Supreme Court per Tabai JSC at page 672 held:

“If at the close of evidence in support of the charge, it appears to the Court that a case is not made out against the Defendant sufficiently to require him to make a defence, the Court shall, as to that particular charge, discharge him. And a discharge following a no case submission under this section has been held to be tantamount to an acquittal.”

In its prayer, the defence submitted that the evidence of PW1 and PW2 and the exhibit tendered — PP.1 — did not and have not revealed any prima facie case of criminal intimidation against the defendant.

“We therefore urge the court to hold that the Prosecution has not established a prima facie case against the Defendant as to compel the court to call upon him to enter his defence. We place reliance on Section 314 of the Kaduna State Administration of Criminal Justice Law 2017 and move the Hon. Court to discharge and acquit the Defendant.”

The defence was filed by Raymond Emeto & Co., Defendant’s Solicitor, De-Awwal House, 1st Floor, 7 Yoruba Road, Kaduna, for service on the Prosecution, C.O.P, Kaduna State, Bida Road, Kaduna.

Recalled that the defendant, Balogun, did not deny calling the complainant journalist on phone after seen the online news report on phone.

By MbNewss

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *